MANY WARRIORS ARE INJURED BEFORE THE REAL BATTLE STARTS: FINDING THE RIGHT LEVEL OF FORCE

Written by

in

The level of contact in martial arts is a fiercely debated subject. Is full-contact training strictly necessary to learn how to fight effectively under real pressure?

Opinions vary, though in my view, if someone is preparing for a competitive bout or works in a role where they may need to fight flat out—such as door security—they need to know what being hit full-on feels like. They also need to be conditioned to take a shot. Boxer Ricky Hatton once wrote that the hardest part of returning to the ring after a layoff is simply getting used to taking a punch again.

However, even those training for real-world violence should not be sparring full contact every single session. It is an unforgiving, prematurely ageing way to train, and countless fighters have seen their careers cut short by injury or sheer wear and tear.

This brings to mind the old adage: “Many warriors are injured before the real battle starts”—a saying reportedly rooted in a traditional Chinese martial arts school known for its highly controlled training methods.

Protective Gear vs. Realistic Conditioning

Body protection can be a useful tool for allowing practitioners to deliver strikes without inflicting serious harm. At the extreme end of this spectrum are “Redman” suits.

While heavily padded and great for practising full-force attacks in self-defence scenarios, their sheer size and bulk restrict the wearer, preventing them from offering truly realistic resistance. Standard sparring gear is a solid middle ground—light enough to let both partners move and spar naturally while still absorbing some of the impact.

That said, wearing pads will never fully prepare you for taking a clean shot. For anyone preparing for full-contact competition or genuine street violence, some experience of unprotected full-contact training is necessary—though personally, I draw the line at bare-knuckle.

Training for Longevity and Everyday Life

Most martial artists I have met do not fall into the competitive fighter category. They train for fitness, enjoyment, and self-improvement.

More importantly, they have to go to work the next morning—something that becomes rather difficult with a broken wrist or cracked ribs. Showing up to the office with black eyes and a broken nose rarely does wonders for a professional image, and most employers take a dim view of sick leave caused by weekend sparring injuries. Factor in lost wages for those who don’t get paid when off sick, and you have a compelling case for exercising common sense on the mat.

I remember attending an open session the day before a grading, where my instructor was helping me polish my techniques. During the warm-up, he was hurling himself onto the mats as hard as possible to practise his breakfalls.

Nearby, an older Aikido student—the type who genuinely embodied the art in martial arts—was performing his own breakfalls smoothly and gracefully. Watching my instructor slam into the floor, the older student asked why he trained so aggressively. My instructor brushed him off, claiming he knew what he was doing. The Aikido practitioner simply replied: “That’s what I thought, until I had to have both knees replaced.”

Consider how much progress is lost to avoidable injuries. A bad tear or break can sideline you for a year, while severe damage can end your training altogether. Regardless of where you stand on contact levels, it is hard to argue that sitting on the sidelines injured is better than training with light-to-medium contact.

While you are recovering, your classmates are improving. Many of us are in martial arts for life, and ageing joints not only injure more easily—they take far longer to heal. You do not need to go flat out to sharpen your timing and technique; in fact, doing so is often counterproductive.

Control Over Force: The Joint Lock Debate

When applying joint locks, there are two distinct schools of thought. One favours cranking every technique hard and fast; the other focuses on applying pressure in a slow, controlled, and progressive manner so your partner has time to tap out before any damage occurs. I come down firmly on the side of control.

Proponents of the “hard and fast” approach argue that it is more realistic for self-defence. Yet joint locks are specifically engineered to inflict maximum damage with minimal force, enabling a smaller, weaker person to defend themselves against a larger attacker.

Slamming on a technique designed to break a small joint as hard as you can is simply asking for trouble—putting tendons, ligaments, and delicate bones at immediate risk. We train to defend ourselves and improve our health, not to cripple our training partners. Even if nothing snaps immediately, the cumulative wear and tear will eventually take its toll.

I do believe pressure should be applied occasionally—both to verify that a technique works and to build tolerance to discomfort so you don’t panic when the heat is on. However, that pressure must always be applied gradually.

I like to compare it to squeezing toothpaste out of a tube. Done smoothly and steadily, you get exactly what you need. Squeeze too hard and fast, and it goes everywhere—and once it’s out, you can’t put it back.

Joint locks work the exact same way: no amount of apologising will un-break a partner’s wrist or give them back the months of training they just lost. Knowing how to apply just enough pressure to cause pain without causing injury takes experience. Until you have mastered that control, always err on the side of caution.

The True Price of Going All-Out

While there is occasionally a place for full-contact striking, I see zero benefit in subjecting your joints to short- or long-term abuse. Long after you hang up your belt, you still have to live in your body.

Ultimately, every individual must decide what level of contact aligns with their goals. While most practitioners stop short of all-out fighting, some love the intensity enough to accept the long-term risks.

I once knew a highly successful competitive kickboxer whose dedication was extraordinary. Every morning before work, he would unlock the gym with a key the owner trusted him with, put in a gruelling heavy-bag session, head to his day job, and return in the evening to train again. One day, he casually mentioned that he already had arthritis in both wrists—despite only being in his early twenties.

Sometime later, I bumped into him and asked how training was going. He explained he was on a mandatory months-long layoff after taking a head shot in a bout that caused internal bleeding on his brain. When I asked what his plans were once he recovered, he looked at me as if I were speaking another language and said, “Get ready for my next fight.”

Respecting the Rules of the Mat

Martial arts means different things to different people, and I respect practitioners across every level of contact. The people I have no time for are those who step into a light- or medium-contact class and deliberately go in heavy—or worse, follow the rules while the instructor is looking, only to throw cheap shots the moment their back is turned.

Sparring exists to sharpen your technique, timing, and composure—not to injure or dominate your training partners. Regardless of how tough a style is, every dojo has rules because sparring is not a street fight.

Combat sports and martial arts carry inherent risks, and those boundaries exist to keep everyone safe while maintaining a level playing field. Problems only arise when someone refuses to grasp the concept of mutual benefit, letting their ego demand a win at all costs—resorting to excessive force or dirty tactics the moment they start getting outclassed.